Forum Mentality: Popularity Reinvented For All Ages
Posted on December 31st, 2007 in Online Experience |
It’s funny. As we grow older, one would have thought we left the popularity contest of “jocks” and “cheerleaders” way behind in some preppy high school. Fitting in? That was a thing of the past. Squeezing into cliques? That’s so 1999! Drama? Pfft, we have lives now. However, the arrival of forums/boards/bbs meant the conglomeration of a wide range of new personalities into a restricted space. And what happens when you place a group of 13 to 30 year-olds, opinionated, hormone-charged, attitude-filled, fast typers onto a website? You get a brand new social experiment*.
* Despite how brilliant (thank you! thank you!) I sound, I do not claim authority on this topic. Far from it. Just like the Internet Epidemics, I’m merely sharing my take on this social phenomenon.
Definitions. When I mention forums, I’m talking about sites like Vindicated MB, Disaster MB, IB Survival Forum, Snark Forum etc.
First impressions. The moment you register your presence on the holy playground of a forum and make a “Newbie” post, YOU ARE JUDGED. Sometimes there will be instant scrutiny (outrageous signature? immature username? that b**** from that loser site here to cause more drama?) and other times, no one really notices/cares. Perhaps for this reason alone, I always lurk around a bit, observe the atmosphere, and check out the posters’ websites first before making a grand (or not) entrance.
Climbing the Post Ladder. Higher numbers always mean SOMETHING in our world. At this point you probably still feel like the “new kid”, simply familiarizing yourself with the lay of the land (wow, what a stupid name for so-and-so board). What originally attracted you to this particular skinning of XMB? Perhaps it is where all the cool people hang out. Perhaps there’s an artsy side that really appealed to you. Show off your talent, individuality, and post, post post.
Avoiding Targets on your Back. On the IB Survival Forum the other day, some idiot started giving me advice on why procrastination is bad and how I can “totally avoid it like the plague!” As a seasoned Year II IBer who has survived most of the storms this idiotic program blows at us, obviously I took this advice sourly. Upon further investigation, I discovered that this poster just entered Year I. What does he know about procrastination, honestly! Now everything post draws a scornful glare on my part. The point is, you want to make an impression for yourself, show that you care, but not care too much that you’re intruding on someone else’s values. Then again, there are some who doesn’t give a damn and just want to share their precious opinions with the world. Go right ahead mes amis.
Fitting in. The concept of fitting in virtually is an odd one. I always felt a connection is established when another poster makes references to YOU specifically, not your post. Sooner or later, inside jokes will run wild and you’ll have a blast picking on some unfortunate newbie with your new “friend”. Of course, ongoing activity must be present to prevent getting dropped from the in-crowd. It sure is a precarious balance.
That’s my two cents on the forum mentality.
Popularity: 86%
No related posts.
I'm Crystal, a Canadian who thinks she can take on the world simply by getting up each morning. They call me the caffeinated IBer wandering on the Internet. 
10 Responses
Psh. Procrastination is the IB student’s specialty. I’m procrastinating as I write this. I hardly know any student in IB, even the so-called “smart” IB overachievers, who don’t do at least some procrastinating. :dead:
Ahh eDrama on forums. I’ve had my fair share of that and may have initiated some eDrama myself. Looking back on it all, I realise that no matter how *distant* people have become because of the internet, that human capacity for conflict (and exclusion) still exists. No matter what “rules” are established to prevent that sort of thing from occurring, it happens anyway.
Ahaha. Sorry, just had to post again as I find the mouse overs on IB quite amusing because IB taught me how to spell Baccalaureate :).
I’ve been on forums pretty much since I started blogging. I probably wanted to see what all the ‘cool’ bloggers were doing and joined the huuge Vortex MB. It was tough fitting in. I didn’t feel like I did. And it closed a couple months after I joined, so I was left to find some other place to go.
Out of all the forums I’ve joined, only two have I ever felt like I belonged — and those two I had been apart of basically from the start — were Vindicated and Splash. I guess it’s because they’re both friendly places where members have some interesting conversation and opinions to offer, not just inside-jokes galore and poking fun at newbies.
All in all, forum-ing is fun, even though sometimes you get annoyed with other members.
Crystal, I’m backkkkkkkkk…
Just for the record, I hate trying to get a new domain! I lost all my money and I’m back on a sub-domain! Woopie!
Right, share time over then
You’re totally right though about the drama. I think being the newbie is always the hardest, it’s like everybody knows each other and you don’t. Like you’ve got to break into the inner circle or whatever.
See yeh on VMB!
Hey! Sorry to have not commented in a while (I’m lazy). Just know that I’ve still been coming by regularly to read all your entries.
Very interesting post. Forums are indeed a totally different social atmosphere. Personally, I think coming to fit in is the hardest part, but it’s easier at places like Vindicated where nearly all the members are friendly and in the same age range. Another thing about VMB is that it’s overall a more intellectual board… while most other boards are more about fashion or inside jokes or vicious web/graphic design competition.
Peace, Crystal!
I agree. I’ve joined plenty of forums, but there were very few that made me feel right at home. I often avoid joining the big and popular forums because most of the members have already established friendships and little cliques so the newbies feel left out. I hate that.
Only a few have made me feel like I fit in. Of course, one of them being VMB. It’s the only forum I’ve ever joined that actually had a balance of fun and intellectual discussions (like Anne said). It also didn’t have those little cliques, so I never felt left out the moment I joined.
At any rate, it passes time when you’re bored. Besides, I for one enjoy coming up with creative insults in e-drama…
Though, many forums have started enforcing this “no fighting” rules. And now basically, whenever people have differing opinions and write more than 3 posts about it, they are labeled as a disturbance and threatened to be banned.
Where’s the fun in joining forums, where you don’t have to try and make a good impression, where you don’t get rewarded for being smart and/or helpful…?
I like Snark because I don’t have to censor every second word that I speak, we get to pull some threads so off topic so much that they end up contaning references to e-drama, Rachael’s (apparently nonexisting) secret double life, cyber law, Jem’s pictures (and secret identity)…
It’s fun.
I’ve always been on forums since I’ve joined the internet because it’s nice to feel a part of something. I must like the experience as a whole because I go back day in, day out. The great thing is meeting new people. The bad thing is meeting the new people. I just try and extract the good things from them (i.e. I’ve met some amazing friends on there) and ignore the rest.
I’m definitely not a DMB fan though. I’ve joined up once or twice but never posted enough for my account to not get deleted.
Although I particularly love drama, especially e-drama, i kind of avoid forums for this particular reason.
Happy New Year!!
http://loveisdead.net/images/newyear08.jpg
Oh nooooo. Fuck those sites! I can not stand them. They are the most boring waste of time. Now, I’m not talking about normal forums for certain topics (like web design or a genre of music or something), I’m talking about these trendfests with domain names containing words like “vintage” or “bomb”. They’re filled with a bunch of ugly people (inside or out) camwhoring or playing silly message board games like “this or that” that only waste space and bandwidth. The classic MB competition: “Who is more scene? A or B.” What a bunch of fake hipsters! These kids can’t tell Andrew Jackson from Jackson Pollock - fuck ‘em!